A world that keeps pulling you back, two leads critics care about, and a few rough edges: the reviews behind GTA 6’s 99 on Metacritic tell a bigger story.
Thirteen years after GTA 5, the first reviews had an enormous question to answer: could the next Grand Theft Auto possibly live up to the wait? Then came 99 points on Metacritic. The number is striking, but the more interesting story lies in what kept the reviewers playing long after they had enough material for a verdict.
IGN, GamesRadar+, VGC and TechRadar Gaming all appear in Metacritic’s critic list with the maximum converted score of 100. Those individual verdicts help explain the overall 99. They also reveal that the enthusiasm is about more than a bigger map or sharper graphics.
A world that outlasts the story
For IGN’s Luke Reilly, the extraordinary detail and freedom to experiment are central to the appeal. His 10/10 verdict treats Leonida as a place to keep interacting with, rather than a backdrop you cross between missions. That distinction runs through the strongest praise: the world keeps giving you reasons to stay.
GamesRadar+ makes that feeling tangible. Josh West describes reaching around 80 hours and still having whole stretches left to explore. He gives GTA 6 five stars, praising the way its systems and incidental encounters work together. The attraction is the thought that the next drive might take you into something you had never planned.
Jason and Lucia give the spectacle a centre
VGC’s Jordan Middler places Jason and Lucia’s relationship at the heart of his five-star review. What matters to him is how the two develop together, including during ordinary time spent travelling through Leonida. The emotional pull gives the crime story something to hold on to between its bigger moments.
TechRadar’s Rob Dwiar finds the same appeal in the contrast between cinematic missions and quieter moments. After almost 100 hours, he awards five stars. His enthusiasm comes from the whole experience: the action, the performances and the freedom to let an ordinary evening in the world become memorable.
Even the five-star reviews have complaints
The high scores do not erase the rough edges. TechRadar points to 30fps, later story lulls and underwhelming interface elements. Those are practical reservations: a slower stretch can interrupt the momentum, and the target frame rate will not suit everyone. Dwiar still finds the overall experience strong enough for the top rating.
VGC also notes occasional frame-rate drops in particularly dense areas on the PS5 version tested. Middler treats them as blemishes on an otherwise exceptional world. GamesRadar+, reviewing on PS5 Pro, is much more positive about stability. Reading the verdicts together gives a fuller picture than assuming every five-star review reports the same experience.
That is the story behind the 99: reviewers repeatedly come back to a world they want to remain in and two people whose next move matters to them. The score summarises that response; the individual reviews explain why it happened. It remains a critic score, separate from user ratings, and can change as more reviews arrive.




