GTA 6 Review Scores Spark “Never Doubt Rockstar” Celebration Among Fans

  • GTAXTREME
  • 3 min read

GTA 6 fans are celebrating a wave of top review scores. Here are the reported ratings, the reasons behind the praise, and the context behind the viral Reddit thread.

GTA 6's first reviews have given fans plenty to celebrate. A November 18 discussion on r/GTA6 titled “Never doubt Rockstar ever again” has become a rallying point for players reacting to the game's critical reception ahead of its November 19 launch.

The Reddit thread mixes excitement, relief and debate about how much weight to put on review scores. The enthusiasm has a clear basis: several major publications awarded Grand Theft Auto VI their highest rating.

GTA 6 review scores at a glance

Tom's Guide's November 18 review roundup reports the following scores. Game Informer's rating is also displayed on its original review.

PublicationScore
IGN10/10
GameSpot10/10
Game Informer10/10
VGC5/5
Eurogamer5/5
Push Square10/10
TheSixthAxis9/10

This is a selection of launch reviews, not an exhaustive list. It also shows why “every reviewer gave it a perfect score” would be an overstatement: even this strongly positive sample contains a nine.

Why reviewers are praising Rockstar's return to Vice City

Matt Miller's Game Informer review, “Outrageous Fortune”, focuses on how the different parts of Leonida work together. Everyday activities, small encounters and environmental detail contribute to a world that remains engaging between the major missions.

Miller also highlights Jason and Lucia's relationship as a central strength, giving the crime story emotional weight. His praise comes with a qualification: some missions prescribe the player's route and actions quite closely. A top score therefore does not mean the reviewer found nothing to criticise.

That distinction matters when reading a score montage. The number communicates an overall verdict; the full review explains the tastes, priorities and reservations behind it.

What about the reported 99 Metacritic score?

PC Gamer's launch coverage reported a Metacritic score of 99 in its November 18 update at 11:27 UTC, describing it as tied with the original The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time.

That is a dated report of an aggregate, rather than a permanently fixed result or a live score on this page. Additional reviews can change the figure, and critic aggregates should not be confused with user ratings. It is also not an objective ruling that one game must be everybody's favourite.

Fans celebrate, while others urge perspective

In the Reddit discussion, many commenters treat the reviews as vindication after the long wait. Others push back against unconditional loyalty to any developer and argue that each release should earn its reputation on its own merits.

Both reactions help explain the thread's appeal: it captures the excitement of a major launch while opening a wider argument about trust, expectations and reviews. Individual comments remain personal reactions, not a representative survey of all GTA players.

For readers avoiding spoilers, the score table above offers a quick overview without discussing story events. Full reviews and their videos may reveal more than their headlines suggest.

GTAXTREME's take: the early critical reception is exceptionally strong. The useful next step is to read beyond the numbers and see whether the reviewers' praise matches what you want from GTA 6. This article reports the reception; it is not our own scored review.

Explore our GTA 6 locations directory as you begin finding your way around Leonida.

Reporting checked on November 19, 2026. Review scores are attributed to the sources linked above; the Reddit post is the source for community reactions.

Explore GTA 6